Wednesday 24 July 2013

9.4.2 HSC Q Feedback

2001

Q9) Hmm a bad start. LCP ONLY relates to “position of equilibrium” ie the %conversion of reactants into products (ie yield). LCP DOES NOT EXPLAIN RATES OF REACTION. Rate of reaction is explained by referring to EA – the greater the proportion of particles with E > EA the greater the rate.

Q10) Look carefully. The second reaction is NOT equilibrium. It goes to completion regardless of what chemicals are added. Adding sodium sulfate will not changethe reactions (ie LCP does not apply). Also –sodium sulphate is a neutral salt. It will not change the acidity of the solution

Q24a) Ammonia is used as a cleaning agent and as a fertilizer (and was used as a refrigerant). Ammonia is used to make urea/fertilizer. Ammonia is used to make nitric acid which in turn is used to make explosives. This is picky but:

·        Nitric acid is not used IN explosives

·        Ammonia is not used IN explosives

·        Technically Ammonia is not used to make explosives

·        Nitric acid is used to manufacture explosives

Q24c) The most logical way to approach all Haber Q is to (once the equation and LCP etc definitions are done) is i) high P (for high yield AND rate), but P limits, ii) High temp for high rate (explain with EA), iii) Low temp for high yield(LCP) , iv) Compromise needed aided by a CATALYST (always mention!), v) Catalyst temp monitored, vi) Then condensing, recycling, gs monitoring (3:1 and O2, CO). This questions was asking you to go through i-iv

2002

Q14) Don’t forget that higher temperatures decrease yield (lower conc of NH3 at equilibrium) but increase rate (equilibrium conc reached sooner = steeper line at thestart).

2003

Q29) This is exactly the same as 2001 Q24c) above but you need to go i-vi including LCP and EA et all the way. It is important to note that

·        You CANNOT answer a Haber/LCP question without an equation. You SHOULD NOT answer any 3+ mark question without writing an equation.

·        high pressure will NOT ‘cause an explosion in the reaction vessel’. An explosion in the vessel would mean that a rapid exothermic reaction initiated (an explosion). Instead high pressure can burst/rupture the reaction vessel.

·        LCP DOES NOT explain rates of reaction

·        ALWAYS name the catalyst as iron, iron oxide or magnetite

·        Remember that the gas stream must be monitored for 1:3 N2:H2 ratio, O2 and CO

·        It is an EVALUTE – thus you need to conclude with a judgement – is it important to monitor….

2005

Q27b) Decreasing volume of the vessel increases the pressure on gases = increases concentration of gases. Each gas conc must jump by the same PERCENTAGE. So if hydrogen conc increases by half its value (1/2H on the pic below), then nitrogen and ammonia must jump by half their original value.
Once the equilibrium shifts, each gas must change according to their mole ratio in the equation Ie for every 1x change in mitogen there will be a 2x change in ammonia and 3x change in hydrogen.

When the Q asks you to explain CHANGES you need to explain ALL the changes ie why the initial spike of all three (increase P = increase conc.), why did ammonia rise and N and H fall (LCP) an why did they come back to  point where their conc. does not change (LCP, ie new equilibrium established).



2006

Q23b) Explain means ‘give reasons’, specifically ‘give chemical reasons’ – so you must use LCP to explain what happens to the OCl- ions, the position of equilibrium, the OH- conc. and thus what happens to the pH
Q24a) THE HABER PROCESS IS AN EQUILIBRIUM REACTION!!!!!!!!!!

Q24b) You should know that Germany was sourcing their nitrates from South America. You should note that the ammonia from the Haber process can be used to manufacture nitrates. Thus, it is important that you mention that ammonia is a raw material for the production of explosives and fertilizers. Also note that it did prolong the war (but not wi it for Germany = lots of death = bad) but in the immediate post war era the fertiizers allowed for increased nutrition and increase in would population.
2008

Q7) This is a strange one. But if you apply your Sherlock Holmes style multiple choice reasoning “When you have eliminated the impossible, whatever remains, however improbable must be the truth” We KNOW that catalysts do not effect equilibrium so it must be B-D, but which of those two are wrong?...

Q23) Again i) Increasing Pressure DOES increase rate of reaction (it increases the concentration of particles with E > EA thus leads to more successful collisions), ii) Even if the Q only said T and P, the fact that a magnetite CATALYST is used allows the temperature compromise – relatively low temp to keep yield acceptable while maintaining a high rate.
2009

Q23) Don’t forget that LCP states that if the conditions of equilibrium are changed the reaction shifts to counteract the change AND A NEW EQUILIBRIUM IS ESTABLISHED. Thus it is vital that you note a new equilibrium is established after each change (ie at 8, 12 and 16 min).The change at 14mi is a increase in volume (decrease in pressure). The drop in all their concentrations just reflects their sudden drop in concentration. THEN the LCP applies showing a small shift to the right before new equilibrium at 16 min.
2010

Q9) this was an interesting Q – just like Sherlock you have to go through each possibility and eliminate the impossible
Q18) This linked LCP and BL acid theory – i) to increase chromate conc do you want to add acid or base and then – which salt do you add?

2011
Q30) This reaction was supposed to be one you have never seen before. You need to apply your understanding of LCP and industrial chemistry (from the Haber topic) to solve it. Some tips: i) look at each equation separately as they are separate steps so each can be done under different conditions, ii) The first reaction, the900oC says that it must be done at 900oC (suggesting a very high activation energy) – so you have no choice on temperature – but what canyou do to pressure, removal of species?, ii) This is just like Haber – don’t forget to consider T, P and catalyst, removal? (but don’t have to know which catalyst), iii) what is different about this reaction. What is the one thing we have to maximise?

2012
Q16) Just like in2005Q27b) you have to be very careful with the relative size of changes in equilibrium graphs. These relative sizes relate to the mole ratio and thus you can determine which species is which.

 Q24) You had to go a couple of steps deep here. i) ammonia to urea/fertilizer to greater crop production nutrition and growth of world population. Ii) ammonia to nitric acid to explosives – used in mining and construction industries allowing for building projects and supplying raw materials for industries/modern world.

No comments:

Post a Comment